OPINIONS

America Was Given a Republic. Now It Has to Prove It Can Keep It.

Published

on

By Chad Dashly | The Current

Benjamin Franklin supposedly walked out of the Constitutional Convention in 1787 and was asked what kind of government the founders had created.

His answer has echoed across more than two centuries:

“A republic, if you can keep it.”

Maybe Franklin wasn’t speaking to 2026.

But he might as well have been.

Because America is approaching a moment when voters will be asked a question much bigger than whether they like Donald Trump, dislike Donald Trump, support Republicans or prefer Democrats.

The real question is whether the institutions of the American republic still matter.

On November 3, 2026, Americans vote in the midterm elections. Every seat in the House of Representatives will be contested, along with roughly one-third of the Senate.

Normally, midterms are about taxes, inflation, health care, immigration and whether voters are satisfied with the president.

This time feels different.

This time the issue is power.

Specifically: How much power should any American president have?

And perhaps more importantly: Who is willing to stop him when he goes too far?

The Problem Isn’t Just Trump

Donald Trump remains the most polarizing political figure in modern American history.

His supporters see a president willing to challenge institutions they believe have become arrogant, unaccountable and hopelessly disconnected from ordinary Americans.

His critics see something much darker: a president steadily testing the limits of executive authority while demanding loyalty from institutions that were designed to remain independent of him.

You don’t need to embrace every accusation levelled against Trump to recognize the danger.

Presidents are supposed to have opposition.

Congress is supposed to challenge the executive.

Courts are supposed to interpret the Constitution independently.

The Justice Department is supposed to administer justice rather than political revenge.

The media is supposed to make powerful people uncomfortable.

Those aren’t inconveniences.

They’re the system.

And when those institutions stop behaving independently, it shouldn’t matter whether the president’s name is Trump, Biden, Obama, Bush or anyone else.

Conservatives, of all people, should understand that.

Limited government cannot mean limited government only when the other party controls it.

Congress Has Forgotten Its Job

Perhaps the most troubling development in Washington is not Trump’s behaviour.

It is Congress’s willingness to surrender its own authority.

America’s founders didn’t create Congress to serve as the president’s fan club.

They created three competing branches of government precisely because they didn’t trust concentrated power.

Ambition was supposed to counter ambition.

Congress was supposed to fight for its authority.

Instead, modern American politics increasingly rewards legislators for becoming extensions of their political tribe.

When their party occupies the White House, congressional leaders defend behaviour they would have condemned had the other side done exactly the same thing.

Democrats have done it.

Republicans have done it.

And the result is an executive branch that gets stronger almost regardless of who wins elections.

That should worry everyone.

Because eventually the president you despise inherits every power you were willing to give the president you loved.

Conservatives Should Be Especially Concerned

There is an uncomfortable irony here.

For decades, conservatives argued for smaller government, constitutional limits, individual liberty and skepticism toward centralized authority.

Those ideas were right then.

They’re right now.

Yet parts of the American right increasingly seem willing to tolerate enormous executive authority so long as the person wielding it is Donald Trump.

That’s not conservatism.

That’s personality politics.

A conservative shouldn’t want a Republican king any more than a Democratic one.

The entire point of constitutional government is that good institutions protect citizens from bad leaders—and protect the country from the excesses of popular ones.

If your theory of government depends entirely upon trusting the character of the person sitting behind the Resolute Desk, you no longer have limited government.

You have faith.

America’s Institutions Are Being Tested

There is another problem developing alongside political power: economic power.

America’s technology giants have become some of the most influential institutions ever created.

They control communications platforms, cloud infrastructure, artificial intelligence, advertising networks and increasingly large portions of the information Americans consume.

That concentration deserves scrutiny regardless of whether those executives are friendly with Democrats or Republicans.

The danger isn’t simply billionaires becoming involved in politics.

Billionaires have always been involved in politics.

The danger comes when political power, technological power, financial power and media power become increasingly intertwined.

A functioning republic depends upon competing centres of authority.

When everybody with something to lose decides it is easier to accommodate political power than challenge it, accountability disappears remarkably quickly.

Courage becomes expensive.

Silence becomes profitable.

That isn’t healthy for democracy.

This Is What the Midterms Are Really About

The 2026 midterms therefore aren’t simply a referendum on Donald Trump.

They’re a referendum on checks and balances.

Americans will decide whether Congress should continue marching alongside the White House or whether Washington needs more institutional friction.

And friction isn’t necessarily dysfunction.

Sometimes friction is exactly what constitutional government requires.

Presidents hate congressional investigations.

Administrations hate hostile committees.

Political parties hate divided government.

Good.

They are supposed to.

The American system was intentionally designed to make sweeping concentrations of power difficult.

Government wasn’t supposed to operate like a corporation with a chief executive issuing orders to compliant subordinates.

It was supposed to be messy.

Slow.

Argumentative.

Frustrating.

That’s a feature, not a bug.

America Doesn’t Need Another King

There is a tendency in modern politics to treat every election as an existential event.

Lose this election and democracy ends.

Lose that election and America disappears.

Most of the time, that’s nonsense.

America has survived terrible presidents, mediocre presidents, corrupt politicians, wars, depressions, scandals and periods of astonishing political stupidity.

It will probably survive Donald Trump too.

But survival isn’t the standard.

The question is what kind of country emerges afterward.

Because republics rarely disappear overnight.

Institutions erode gradually.

Norms become optional.

Exceptional measures become routine.

Political opponents become enemies.

Executive authority expands.

Legislatures become spectators.

And eventually people discover that powers they tolerated when their side was winning have become terrifying when the other side takes control.

That is why Franklin’s warning still matters.

Keeping the Republic Is the Voters’ Job

The founders didn’t promise America permanent liberty.

They built machinery that could preserve it.

But the machinery only works if citizens demand that it work.

That means insisting presidents obey constitutional limits even when you voted for them.

It means expecting Congress to act like an independent branch of government.

It means defending courts when they issue decisions you dislike.

It means tolerating journalism that makes your side uncomfortable.

It means accepting that political opponents are still citizens.

And above all, it means remembering that America is bigger than whoever happens to occupy the White House.

Donald Trump isn’t America.

Neither is the Republican Party.

Neither is the Democratic Party.

America is the Constitution.

The institutions.

The separation of powers.

The rule of law.

And the stubborn idea that nobody—not a billionaire, not a judge, not a president—is supposed to be above them.

Franklin said America had been given a republic if it could keep it.

Nearly 240 years later, Americans are still answering him.

On November 3, they get another chance.

Footnote: Chad Dashly has a clear thesis: the issue isn’t whether you love or hate Trump; it’s whether you still believe in limited government when your own side controls it.

OPINIONS

Doerkson has his majority. Now B.C. needs to see his plan.

Published

on

Opinion | Doerkson has his majority. Now B.C. needs to see his plan.

By Chad Dashly | The Current | November 19, 2026

In Victoria, 63 Conservative MLAs are scheduled to take the oath of office Thursday. In Kelowna Centre, 43 votes separate the two candidates, and the incumbent will have to wait. Both are part of the same transfer of power. British Columbians made a clear choice about who should govern, and two communities are still waiting for the courts to confirm who will represent them.

On Friday, Lieutenant Governor Wendy Cocchia is scheduled to swear in Lorne Doerkson as B.C.’s 38th premier at Government House, where his cabinet will also be sworn in. Doerkson took over as interim Conservative leader just days before David Eby called the snap election. Eby said he needed a stronger mandate to respond to U.S. tariffs. Voters gave that mandate to the Conservatives, and Eby resigned as NDP leader after the Oct. 24 vote. Nine years of NDP government are coming to an end.

Two ridings are still waiting

Elections BC’s final count put the Conservatives at 64 seats, the NDP at 27 and the Greens at two. Those totals include the candidates leading in two ridings that are subject to automatic judicial recounts. That’s why 63 Conservatives are scheduled to take the oath Thursday. Elections BC

  • Kelowna Centre. Conservative incumbent Kristina Loewen finished 43 votes ahead of New Democrat Loyal Wooldridge. Loewen is expected to attend Thursday’s ceremony, with her oath deferred pending the recount scheduled for Monday, Nov. 23.

  • Ladysmith–Oceanside. NDP incumbent Stephanie Higginson finished 50 votes ahead of Conservative Kris McNichol. Higginson’s swearing-in depends on the recount and certification of the result. The NDP caucus ceremony is scheduled for Thursday, Nov. 26. Green MLAs Emily Lowan and Jeremy Valeriote are scheduled to take their oaths Monday, Nov. 23.

Both recounts are required because the margin was less than one five-hundredth of the ballots considered in each riding. The Conservatives have a majority whichever way those counts go. For people in Kelowna Centre and Ladysmith–Oceanside, the outcome still determines who answers their calls and speaks for them in Victoria. That matters every day between elections.

No fall sitting means fewer chances to ask hard questions

Doerkson says his ministers will get to work immediately and prepare legislation for the spring. His government has decided against a fall sitting. A new cabinet needs time to get across its files, but the decision also means opposition MLAs lose the chance to question ministers on the floor of the legislature this fall. The government can make up some of that ground by publishing ministerial mandates, setting deadlines and making ministers available to answer for their early decisions.

Start with the books. The province’s first-quarter update projected a $13.8-billion deficit for 2026–27. That figure is a forecast for one fiscal year. If the Conservatives intend to bring it down, British Columbians deserve to know what they’ll change, what services they’ll protect and how soon they expect to see results. Those answers matter to a family waiting for a doctor in the Interior and to a small manufacturer trying to decide whether it can afford to hire through tariff uncertainty.

Friday’s cabinet appointments will tell us who has been given the work. By spring, British Columbians should be able to see what each minister has done with it. Doerkson has enough seats to make decisions. He can start earning trust by showing the public how he makes them.

Continue Reading

OPINIONS

Save Local Journalism—Including the Voices Outside the Big Chains

Published

on

Save Local Journalism—Including the Voices Outside the Big Chains

By Chad Dashly | Opinion | The Current

When the big newspaper groups warn that local journalism is in trouble, we should listen.

When they ask government to help pay the bills, we should ask questions.

Both are part of a healthy democracy.

B.C.’s community newspaper industry is calling for a greater share of provincial advertising spending to stay with local publishers. Its argument deserves consideration: governments need to communicate with residents, and local news outlets need advertising revenue to keep reporting.

But there is a bigger question behind that request.

Will any new arrangement support a diverse local press, including independent digital publishers, or simply help the largest established players hold their ground?

That distinction matters to every community that wants more than one version of the story.

Journalism belongs to the community

Peter Kvarnstrom reports that Black Press community newspapers and eight Glacier publications produced more than 7,000 election stories and columns during October’s municipal and provincial campaigns. That represents substantial work by reporters helping voters understand their choices.

Those journalists deserve credit. A reporter working for a large chain can be just as committed to their community as someone working for a small independent outlet.

But the number of stories a company publishes does not give it ownership of the public interest.

Independent outlets bring additional questions, different editorial judgments and another place for residents to take concerns. Sometimes they pursue an issue others have overlooked. Sometimes they challenge a comfortable local consensus.

Readers benefit from that competition.

A town with several outlets asking questions has a better chance of getting answers than a town depending on one editorial desk.

Public advertising needs public rules

The industry’s proposal calls for at least 25 per cent of government advertising spending to go to local media. Kvarnstrom has advocated extending that approach to Crown corporations as well.

Let’s be precise: purchasing advertising is a commercial transaction. It is different from handing a newsroom an unrestricted operating grant.

Government has legitimate reasons to buy advertising. Residents need information about public services, road closures, emergency preparedness and programs their taxes support.

The test should be whether that spending reaches people effectively, delivers value and follows fair, published rules.

An independent digital publisher should have a fair opportunity to compete. So should a community newspaper, a local broadcaster or another credible outlet serving an identifiable audience.

Owning a printing press should confer no special claim on taxpayers’ money. Neither should belonging to a large publishing group.

And favourable coverage must never become an unofficial qualification.

Independence requires more than a label

Receiving government advertising does not automatically compromise a newsroom. Refusing it does not automatically make a publication trustworthy.

Independence is demonstrated through conduct: checking facts, correcting mistakes, separating advertising from editorial decisions and asking difficult questions even when the answers might upset someone who pays the bills.

That applies to governments. It also applies to private advertisers, owners and political allies.

Still, any system that puts public officials in charge of allocating revenue to the outlets covering them deserves close scrutiny.

Publish the recipients. Publish the amounts. Explain the selection criteria. Make access fair for smaller publishers.

Public confidence requires that much.

Readers and businesses have a role

Government spending alone cannot provide a durable foundation for independent journalism.

Local businesses make a choice every time they place an advertisement. Readers make one when they subscribe, contribute, share an original report or introduce a publication to a potential advertiser.

Those choices help determine which voices survive.

At The Current, we believe communities deserve reporting and commentary that earn their attention, challenge decisions and give people a reason to stay engaged.

We also believe readers should be able to compare our work with someone else’s.

So yes, take the financial crisis facing local journalism seriously.

But if government changes how it buys advertising, the objective should be a stronger, more varied local press.

The big boys deserve a fair hearing. Independent publishers deserve a fair chance. And the public deserves a press nobody can take for granted.

Continue Reading

OPINIONS

The Money Spoke Before the Voters Did: How B.C.’s Conservatives Turned Chaos Into Victory

Published

on

The Money Spoke Before the Voters Did: How B.C.’s Conservatives Turned Chaos Into Victory

By Chad Dashly | The Current | November 5, 2026

There is an old saying in politics: follow the money.

In British Columbia, the money was telling a story long before voters went to the polls on October 24. And if anyone at NDP headquarters was paying attention, they should have been worried.

New third-quarter fundraising figures show the Conservative Party of British Columbia raised approximately $2.73 million, compared with just $986,093 for the NDP.

Nearly three dollars for the Conservatives for every dollar raised by the New Democrats.

But the real story isn’t simply how much money came in. It’s when it arrived — and what that tells us about the extraordinary political transformation British Columbia has just experienced.

From Political Chaos to Political Capital

Only weeks before the election, the BC Conservatives appeared to be doing everything possible to destroy themselves.

Leadership disputes. Caucus defections. Public disagreements. A party seemingly more interested in fighting itself than fighting the government.

Then came September 20.

Kerry-Lynne Findlay resigned as Conservative leader, and Cariboo-Chilcotin MLA Lorne Doerkson stepped into the leadership.

What happened next should become a case study for political strategists across Canada.

Between September 20 and September 30, Conservative contributions totalled approximately $2.45 million — nearly 90 per cent of the party’s entire third-quarter fundraising.

Think about that.

A party struggling to hold itself together suddenly attracted millions of dollars in political contributions in just eleven days.

That doesn’t happen by accident.

It suggests donors who had been sitting on the sidelines were suddenly prepared to invest in a political organization they believed could win.

The change in leadership mattered. So did the prospect of an election. And the Conservatives had something they hadn’t possessed in months: a credible opportunity to unite their competing factions around a common objective.

Winning.

David Eby’s Political Miscalculation

Premier David Eby called a snap election on September 22, two years ahead of the scheduled provincial vote.

The calculation appeared straightforward.

The Conservatives were divided. Their leadership had collapsed. Their caucus had fractured. Surely this was the moment to strike.

Except something had changed.

The Conservative Party that Eby expected to face was rapidly becoming a different political organization.

Doerkson’s arrival created an opportunity for reconciliation among Conservatives who had spent months arguing about personalities, policies and direction.

And the fundraising figures suggest that opportunity resonated.

Meanwhile, the NDP struggled to generate comparable financial enthusiasm.

That is not necessarily proof that donors predicted the election result. Political contributions are influenced by many factors, including campaign timing, organizational strength and individual donor networks.

But the disparity was an unmistakable warning.

Eby may have correctly identified Conservative instability. What he appears to have underestimated was how quickly that instability could turn into unity when the prospect of forming government became real.

The Interior Has Become the Centre of Political Power

There is another dimension to this election that deserves attention.

British Columbia’s political centre of gravity has shifted.

For decades, provincial politics has been dominated by Vancouver, Victoria and the Lower Mainland.

Now a politician from the Cariboo-Chilcotin is preparing to lead the province.

That matters.

For communities throughout the Thompson, Okanagan, Cariboo and northern British Columbia, the election represents an opportunity to bring regional economic concerns directly into the premier’s office.

Forestry. Mining. Natural gas. Agriculture. Transportation infrastructure. Permitting delays.

These are not abstract policy debates for people who live and work outside the Lower Mainland.

They determine whether businesses invest, whether young families can remain in their communities and whether the next generation has meaningful economic opportunities.

Doerkson has promised to make economic development a priority.

The question now is whether his government can turn those promises into measurable results.

Money Can Win Elections. It Cannot Govern.

Conservatives should be careful about celebrating too early.

Preliminary election results give the party 63 of the legislature’s 93 seats, although the final count is still pending.

That is a commanding position.

But a large majority does not automatically produce a successful government.

The same party that recently struggled with internal divisions must now demonstrate cabinet discipline, sound fiscal management and the ability to make difficult decisions.

British Columbians will expect progress on affordability, health care, housing and economic opportunity.

They will also expect accountability.

The Conservatives have promised no new taxes, faster approvals for major projects and stronger support for resource development.

Delivering those commitments while maintaining essential public services will require more than campaign slogans.

It will require serious governing.

The Lesson for Every Political Party

The fundraising numbers reveal something larger than a financial advantage.

They suggest a dramatic change in political confidence.

Donors were willing to back the Conservatives despite the party’s recent turmoil. Voters subsequently handed them a decisive preliminary victory.

For the NDP, the implications are equally significant.

A party that controlled the government machinery and chose the election date was unable to match its opponent’s fundraising momentum.

That demands more than a routine campaign review.

It demands an examination of leadership, organization, voter relationships and the party’s understanding of the province’s changing political priorities.

For the Conservatives, the challenge is different.

They have won the opportunity to govern. Now they must prove they deserve to keep it.

The money may have spoken before the voters did. But from this point forward, British Columbians will judge their new government not by what it raised, but by what it delivers.

Chad Dashly writes political commentary for The Current, examining British Columbia politics, public policy and the decisions shaping communities across the province.

Continue Reading

Trending